I guess the first thing
to cover would be to define citizen journalism. According to Luke Goode,
citizen journalism is associated with the internet; however, this is not always
the case, citizen journalism does not always necessarily stay online. Sometimes
professional journalists will use eyewitness accounts, pictures, or video footage
as well as information found on the blogs of citizen journalists. Also, print
media sometimes have columns written by citizen journalists called soapbox
features. However, when the world of both the traditional journalism and
citizen journalists collide, the boundaries start to become increasingly
indistinct. He goes further to define the citizen journalist as being more than
someone who simply comments, reposts, or tags pictures on random websites. A
citizen journalist is someone who actually captures news worthy events as it is
happening and shares it with the rest of the world. The scope of the citizen
journalist is not limited to breaking news events. Investigative journalism is
also becoming more prevalent in the world of amateur news. A person researching
a company, business, or government agency for any number of reasons may stumble
upon some sort of scandal or potential wrong doing relating to that entity. If
this person takes this information and brings it to the public’s attention,
they have just become a citizen journalist. Mr. Goode goes further to explain
that we cannot ignore or dismiss the potential impact that citizen journalism
has on traditional journalism. One of the problems with nontraditional
journalism is the lack of regulation. A citizen journalist can take a story and
rework, change, or alter a story as it is circulating online; therefore,
changing the original story. In fact, without anyone to answer to or guidelines
to adhere to, they can simply make up their own news and post it online. (2009)
The average American is
getting more and more involved in the political process, thanks in part to
blogging and citizen journalism. James Surowiecki said in his TED Talk video
that, “we are giving people that have never been able to talk before a voice,
and we are able to access information that has always been there but has gone
essentially untapped.” (2005) Before the world became so utterly and instantly
connected, we were unable to discuss things like news, current events, and
politics outside of our friends, family, and coworkers. With the communication
technologies now available to us, we can talk to virtually anyone, anywhere, at
any time. Today, people can go online and create blogs, websites, and profiles
to discuss and promote anything and everything. Scattered throughout the
seemingly never ending sea of information at our fingertips is citizen
journalism. Sometimes you can find it were you least expect it. Mena Trott
created a blog with the sole purpose of leaving a legacy of herself for the future
generations of her family. She felt it was important to make a record of herself
so that they could know who she was, beyond what memories of her that had been
passed down. (2006) Though this blog is very personal in nature, it has the
potential to be a platform for journalism. For instants, if in one of her daily
posts she happened to mention a car crash that she had witnessed then that
could be considered citizen journalism. By posting the when, where, and what
type of vehicles were involved and so forth, she would be considered a citizen
journalist.
Of course there are
draw backs to citizen journalism. James Surowieck mentions the following about
blogging in general, that people tend to lose their individuality. They jump on
a band wagon about a particular topic and begin to lose their own opinion on
the issue in favor of the views of the majority within the group. (2005) This
behavior could have an impact on citizen journalism. For example, say a person
were to post a story based on some information he or she had. Then the person also
read another post about the same story, that person is more likely to change
their story to match the other story not knowing if the facts in the other
story were true or accurate. This is when citizen journalist should always
fact-check their information. Chris Measures, who has had 15 years of PR
experience, suggests there are three reasons why people should be wary of
citizen journalism:
1.
Citizen journalists
tend to be bias. Professional journalists are trained professionals that look
at both sides of a story and can write from a non-objective point of view.
Citizen journalist does not have the type of training; therefore, their stories
are not as credible as professionals.
2.
Citizen
journalists are not trained on the libel law. Professional journalists do have
this knowledge and training. They know what they can and cannot say in a news
story. An example of this is when citizen journalists wrongfully accused potential
suspects and alleged co-conspirators during and after the Boston marathon bombings.
The citizen journalists caused the police to take longer on the investigation.
It also caused huge problems for those that were wrongfully accused.
3.
Last but not
least, citizen journalists do not realize the copyright issues. Once a citizen
submits a story, video, or picture to the press or news site, that news sources
has the right to use the material however they choose to use it. (2013)
Even though Chris
Measures brings up three good points about why we should be wary of citizen
journalism, the fact is they are not going away any time soon. Professional
journalists and citizen journalists can learn a lot from each other and work
together in creating the news. When citizens see things that are news worthy,
they should tell professional journalists the story and details and let the
professionals research the story more thoroughly and write the articles.
However, there is no way to convince everyone in the world to do that, so for
now my advice would be to always fact-check what you read online. Thank you for
reading.
References:
Goode, L. (2009). Social news, citizen journalism
and democracy. New Media & Society, 11 (8), 1287-1305. Doi:10.1177/1461444809341393
http://socialmediatoday.com/chris-measures/1430031/rise-citizen-journalism